Key Topics:

1. The evolution of China's digital diplomacy

2. Social media Platforms Used by China

3. Case study: China's social media influence during COVID-19

4. The Belt and Road Initiative's digital strategy

5. China's social media tactics during the 2022 Winter Olympics

6. Ethical implications and concerns

7. Future trends in China's digital diplomacy

8. Expert analysis and recommendations
    

China's Digital Diplomacy: A Historical Perspective

It's crucial to examine China's historical context and evolution to fully comprehend its current digital diplomacy strategies.

Early Stages (2000-2010)

In the early 2000s, China's global digital presence was limited. The government's focus was primarily on controlling domestic internet content and developing social media platforms such as Weibo and WeChat (Deng, 2019). During this period, China's international communication largely relied on traditional media outlets like CCTV (now CGTN) and the Xinhua News Agency (Li, 2021).

​

Emergence of Digital Diplomacy (2010-2015)

The Arab Spring of 2010-2011 marked a turning point in China's approach to digital diplomacy. Recognizing the power of social media in shaping political movements, the Chinese government began exploring ways to leverage these platforms for its messaging (Shen, 2020). This period saw the gradual emergence of Chinese diplomatic accounts on Twitter and Facebook, despite these platforms being blocked within China (Wang, 2016).

​

The "Telling China's Story Well" Era (2015-2019)

In 2015, President Xi Jinping called for a more proactive approach to international communication, emphasizing the need to "tell China's story well" (Xu, 2018). This directive led to a significant expansion of China's digital diplomacy efforts, characterized by several key developments:

• Increased presence of Chinese diplomats and state media on Western social media platforms

• Development of multilingual content strategies

• Integration of digital diplomacy with broader foreign policy initiatives, such as the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) (Zhao, 2019)

• ​

The "Wolf Warrior" Phase (2019-Present)

Named after a popular Chinese action movie, the "wolf warrior" diplomacy phase has been characterized by a more assertive and sometimes confrontational approach on social media. Chinese diplomats and officials have increasingly vocalized their defense of China's interests and challenged critics online. Dr. Yun Sun, Director of the China Program at the Stimson Center, notes, "The shift towards 'wolf warrior' diplomacy reflects China's growing confidence on the global stage and its desire to shape, rather than merely respond to, international narratives" (Sun, 2021).

​

Social Media Platforms: China's Digital Arsenal

China's digital diplomacy utilizes a diverse array of social media platforms, each serving specific strategic purposes.

​

Western Platforms

• Twitter
  Primary use: Official communications, real-time responses to global events
  Key actors: Chinese diplomats, state media accounts
  Example: Zhao Lijian, spokesperson for China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, has over 1.2 million followers (Wang, 2020).

• Facebook
  Primary use: Long-form content, video sharing
  Key actors: State media outlets (e.g., Xinhua, CGTN)
  Reach: CGTN's Facebook page has over 115 million followers (Zhao, 2021).

• YouTube
  Primary use: Documentary-style content, cultural promotion
  Key actors: State media channels, cultural institutions
  Example: CGTN's YouTube channel has over 2 million subscribers (Li, 2022).

• LinkedIn
  Primary use: Professional networking, thought leadership
  Key actors: Chinese companies, government agencies
  Strategy: Promoting China as a business and innovation leader.

• ​

Chinese Platforms with Global Reach

• TikTok
  Owned by Chinese company ByteDance, TikTok has a global user base of over 1 billion monthly active users. The platform focuses on short-form videos, often featuring Chinese culture and achievements.

• WeChat
  While primarily used within China, WeChat is growing in international presence. Its features include messaging, social media, and mobile payments, strategically connecting overseas Chinese communities and facilitating business communications.

Platform-Specific Strategies

China's approach varies significantly across platforms. On Twitter, the tone is often more formal and sometimes confrontational, reflecting the "wolf warrior" diplomacy style. In contrast, content on platforms like TikTok and YouTube tends to be more culturally focused and aimed at promoting soft power. Dr. Mareike Ohlberg, Senior Fellow at the German Marshall Fund, observes: "China's multi-platform strategy allows it to tailor its messaging to different audiences. While Twitter might be used for policy statements, platforms like TikTok are more effective for cultural diplomacy and reaching younger demographics" (Ohlberg, 2021).

Case Study: China's Social Media Influence During COVID-19

The COVID-19 pandemic provided a unique case study of China's digital diplomacy in action, showcasing both its capabilities and limitations.

Key Strategies Employed

• Narrative Control
  Objective: Shift global perception from China as the origin of the virus to China as a responsible global leader.
  Tactics: Hashtag campaigns (#ChinaAid) and promotion of China's medical assistance to other countries.
  Example: The hashtag #ChinaAid was used over 50,000 times on Twitter in March 2020 (Chen, 2020).

• Disinformation and Conspiracy Theories
  Tactic: Promoting alternative theories about the virus's origin.
  Example: Zhao Lijian's tweet suggesting U.S. military involvement in bringing the virus to Wuhan generated significant controversy and diplomatic tensions (Sun, 2020).

• Amplification of Positive Voices
  Strategy: Highlighting praise from foreign leaders and international organizations.
  Example: Widespread sharing of WHO officials' comments praising China's response.

• Coordinated Inauthentic Behavior
  Tactic: Use of bot networks and coordinated accounts to amplify pro-China narratives.
  Detection: In June 2020, Twitter removed over 170,000 accounts linked to Chinese state-backed operations (Wong, 2020).

Effectiveness and Backlash

The effectiveness of China's COVID-19 social media campaign was mixed. Positive outcomes included increased visibility of China's medical aid efforts. However, negative consequences involved heightened skepticism in Western countries due to aggressive messaging and disinformation attempts. Dr. Yanzhong Huang, Senior Fellow for Global Health at the Council on Foreign Relations, notes, "While China's social media campaign during COVID-19 may have resonated in some developing countries, it often backfired in Western nations, leading to increased scrutiny of China's digital diplomacy tactics" (Huang, 2021).

The Belt and Road Initiative's Digital Strategy

The Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), China's ambitious global infrastructure project, has a significant digital component that leverages social media for promotion and engagement.

Social Media Strategies for BRI

• Hashtag Campaigns
  Primary hashtags: #BeltandRoad, #BRI.
  Usage: Over 500,000 posts using these hashtags on Twitter in 2020 (Li, 2020).
  Purpose: Highlight BRI projects and their benefits.

• Visual Storytelling
  Platforms: Instagram, YouTube.
  Content: High-quality videos and images showcasing BRI projects.
  Example: CGTN's "New Silk Road" documentary series on YouTube, with millions of views.

• Localized Content
  Strategy: Tailored content in local languages for BRI partner countries.
  Example: China Daily's Africa Facebook page has over 4 million followers.

• Influencer Partnerships
  Tactic: Collaborating with local social media influencers in BRI countries.
  Example: In 2019, Chinese state media partnered with Kenyan influencers to promote the Mombasa-Nairobi Railway project (Xu, 2019).

• Countering Criticism
  Focus: Addressing concerns about "debt-trap diplomacy" and environmental impact.
  Tactic: Direct rebuttals by Chinese officials on Twitter.

Effectiveness and Challenges

The BRI social media strategy has seen varying degrees of success, with positive outcomes in increasing visibility and understanding of BRI projects in partner countries. Challenges remain, including persistent concerns about China's intentions and the long-term impacts of the BRI, with regional variations in reception (Ye, 2021).

China's Social Media Strategy During the 2022 Winter Olympics

The 2022 Winter Olympics in Beijing presented China with a unique opportunity to showcase its achievements and culture to a global audience. The social media strategy employed during this event offers insights into China's evolving digital diplomacy approach.

Key Elements of the Olympic Social Media Campaign

• Cultural Promotion
  Platforms: TikTok, Instagram, YouTube.
  Content: Short, engaging videos about Chinese traditions, cuisine, and Olympic venues.
  Reach: Over 2 billion views for Olympics-related content on TikTok (Li, 2022).

• Athlete Spotlights
  Strategy: Highlighting stories of Chinese athletes.
  Example: Eileen Gu, a Chinese-American freestyle skier, became a focal point with millions of engagements across platforms.

• Virtual Experiences
  Tactic: Leveraging social media for virtual tours and behind-the-scenes content.
  Purpose: Engage a global audience despite limited in-person attendance due to COVID-19.

• Hashtag Campaigns
  Primary hashtag: #TogetherForASharedFuture.
  Usage: Over 1 million posts across platforms.

• Countering Negative Narratives
  Focus: Responding to human rights concerns, particularly regarding Xinjiang.
  Tactic: Coordinated messaging from state media and officials.

Challenges and Controversies

The Olympic social media campaign faced several challenges, including allegations of inauthentic activity and competing narratives from Western media focusing on human rights issues (Sung, 2022). Dr. Wen-Ti Sung, Political Scientist at the Australian National University, notes, "The 2022 Olympics social media strategy highlighted China's growing sophistication in digital diplomacy, but also exposed the limitations of its

messaging in the face of global scrutiny" (Sung, 2022).

Conclusion

China's digital diplomacy has undergone a significant transformation over the past two decades, evolving from a focus on content control to a proactive, multi-platform strategy that leverages social media to promote its narratives and counter criticisms. As China continues to navigate the complexities of global diplomacy in the digital age, its social media tactics will remain central to shaping international perceptions and influencing foreign audiences. While challenges and controversies persist, the adaptability and ambition demonstrated by China in this arena signal a growing recognition of the importance of digital platforms in contemporary diplomacy.

References

1. Chen, L. (2020). "China's Digital Diplomacy: The Case of COVID-19." Asian Journal of Communication.

2. Deng, Y. (2019). "China's Digital Diplomacy: Opportunities and Challenges." International Journal of Communication.

3. Huang, Y. (2021). "COVID-19 and China's Digital Diplomacy." Council on Foreign Relations.

4. Li, J. (2021). "Social Media and China's Global Narrative." Journal of Chinese Political Science.

5. Li, S. (2022). "Beijing 2022: China's Olympic Social Media Strategy." China Media Project.

6. Sun, Y. (2020). "China's Disinformation Campaign During COVID-19." Foreign Affairs.

7. Sun, Y. (2021). "The 'Wolf Warrior' Diplomacy: A New Phase in China's Foreign Policy." The Diplomat.

8. Wang, Q. (2016). "Chinese Diplomats on Social Media: A New Era of Communication." The China Quarterly.

9. Wang, X. (2020). "Twitter Diplomacy: The Rise of Chinese Officials on Social Media." International Studies Review.

10. Wong, J. (2020). "Twitter's Removal of Chinese Bot Accounts: Implications for Digital Diplomacy." The Diplomat.

11. Xu, T. (2018). "Telling China's Story: The Evolution of China's International Communication Strategy." Chinese Journal of Communication.

12. Xu, T. (2019). "The Belt and Road Initiative: A Social Media Perspective." Asia-Pacific Journal of Communication.

13. Ye, L. (2021). "Public Perception of China's Belt and Road Initiative: A Global Survey." China Quarterly.

14. Zhao, S. (2019). "China's Soft Power and Digital Diplomacy: The Case of the Belt and Road Initiative." Journal of Global Policy.

15. Zhao, Z. (2021). "China's Social Media Influence in Global Politics." Journal of Chinese Political Science.